How this was made
- Picked the agencies. Founder-led US agencies and dev shops, about 10 to 249 people, pulled from a business database and screened for fit from each homepage.
- Loaded each homepage as a visitor sees it. Chrome at 1440px wide, scrolled top to bottom so images load, with cookie banners and chat pop-ups hidden, never clicked.
- Scored every page on eight buyer questions, 0 to 3 each: what you do, who it's for, the client's problem, why you over the alternatives, what they get, why to believe you, what to do next, and the one thing to remember. Each score of 2 or 3 cites the page's own words. Page titles and meta descriptions don't count, since visitors don't read them.
- Checked the scoring. A second reader scored 99 pages separately: 82% of question scores matched exactly and every one was within a point.
- Picked sections on the top pages. Every homepage scoring 16 of 24 or more had each section tagged by type. A section is picked when it does at least two of the strong moves for its type with specifics: the client's own words, names, numbers, a named method or a real limit. By page shows homepages with three or more picks.
What this can't see: design quality, page speed, and whether a page actually books calls. Portfolio-first sites with little copy are scored as their own group and aren't ranked against the rest. Sites change, so a live page may look different today. Every card links to it.